Robberies are running rampant in Little Valley, and the quiet small-town lives of the Amish community are suddenly thrown into chaos. Trusting that the local sheriff and deputy team have everything under control, things get even worse when the sheriff is found dead and their beloved shop owner stands accused of murder.
Amish twin sisters, well known as the wise women in their community, step up to do their own investigation alongside a brash big city detective. Whether he likes it or not, the women are determined to help solve the complicated crimes of theft and murder and clear their family name.
The two amateur investigators soon question whether they are in over their heads and begin to doubt if they can solve the mysteries in front of them…
Levi expected to meet Ruby at their secret spot in the woods, but she was nowhere to be found. Due to a disagreement earlier that day at the breakfast table, Ruby’s father is faced with a battle of pride as the bishop of the Amish community in the small town of Little Valley. But when Ruby doesn’t come home for dinner, he and his wife begin to worry that Ruby’s disappearance might be more than just a teenage temper tantrum.
The new sheriff finds himself working hard to uncover all the secrets surrounding Ruby’s disappearance and rebuild the community’s confidence in the law. He reaches out to the trusted wise women and amateur investigators, Anna and Beth, for help.
Everywhere the twin sisters turn, another secret is revealed, but the biggest secret of all is about to be uncovered
The Amish community in Little Valley is facing big changes, and big threats, with tourism booming. It becomes clear that some of the new businesses want control of the market, and it looks like they are willing to go to great lengths to get it.
With one barn after another set on fire in the middle of the night, it becomes personal, and the community is scared for the well-being of their families and their future in Little Valley.
Anna and Beth are considered the wise women in the community and are equipped with a few solved murder mysteries under their belt. The sisters are ready once again to untangle the clues and find the real story behind the fires. Will they be able to solve the mystery and convince the community to stay?
Hazel Thompson is found dead in Little Valley’s now-famous Amish Inn, and there’s a long list of suspects with plenty of motive.
Much to the dismay of the Amish community, the sheriff’s prime suspect is Eva Zook, the owner of the new Amish bakery. In almost Déjà vu fashion, the twin sisters, Anna and Beth, find themselves once again faced with clearing their family’s name, but things are even more complicated than before since the murder weapon has Eva’s prints all over it.
Jessica McLean opens shop to find a man has been left for dead on the floor of her diner. With very few clues left behind, Jessica becomes the prime suspect. But Amish twin sisters and amateur sleuths, Beth and Anna, wonder if the crime could be related to Jessica’s new relationship with their beloved Matthew Beiler.
It soon becomes clear that things aren’t always as they seem. Will the sisters step in and solve the mystery, bringing justice to Little Valley yet again?
The Little Valley library is shutting its doors due to a terrible combination of anonymous threats and a lack of funding.
The sheriff is stumped in the investigation of who is sending the threats, so amateur sleuths, Anna and Beth, step in to help. But before they can get to the bottom of it, Beth volunteers to organize a fundraising Christmas fair for the library in spite of everything the sisters already have on their plates with the upcoming holiday. Anna is reluctant at first, but soon joins in on the festivities.
Little Valley’s Christmas fair suddenly feels a lot less festive, however, when the library’s well-known assistant is found murdered behind the mystery bookshelves, a new anonymous note found next to her body.
Facing their biggest challenge ever, will the twin sister dynamic duo be able to help the detective solve the case, save the library and save Christmas for the town, too?